|
Achievement is the
kind of word that provokes an assortment of
potential definitions. Some might argue that
success alone defines achievement, even if that
success involves unimportant problems. Others
might suggest that success is trivial unless it
occurs on important problems, even if those
problems are easy to solve. Still others might
maintain that achievement is a word best reserved
for success on important, difficult problems that
the private and nonprofit sectors simply cannot
solve on their own.
The term becomes
even more difficult to define when it is linked to
government. Some would argue that government
should only engage in endeavors that show the
promise of impact, others that government should
reserve its energies only for important goals, and
still others that government should concentrate
its effort on important, difficult problems that
no other sector can tackle.
This study draws a
bit of insight from all three arguments, scoring
the list of government’s greatest endeavors by
putting the heaviest weight on success, while
awarding extra credit for tackling important,
difficult problems. Toward that end, government
achievement is defined as six parts success, three
parts importance, and one part difficulty, with
the final score a sum of the weighted ratings on
each of the 50 endeavors. Although the emphasis
here is undeniably on the government’s actual
impact, this scoring method declares a basic
preference for aiming high. Using this scoring
approach, the federal government’s top ten
achievements, or greatest hits, emerge as follows (more
on methodology):
1. Rebuild
Europe After World War II.
Rebuilding Europe is the oldest endeavor on the
top ten list, and is anchored in the Foreign
Assistance Act of 1948, better known as the
Marshall Plan. It is also the only endeavor on
the top ten list that is no longer active.
Launched with the Bretton Woods Agreement of
1945, the nation could declare success by the
end of the 1950s.
2. Expand
the Right to Vote.
Ten statutes comprise this broad effort to
protect and expand the right to vote. Although
the Voting Rights Act of 1965 is the flagship on
the list, it shares the endeavor with three
extensions in 1970, 1975, and 1982, three
earlier statutes (the 1957, 1960, and 1964 Civil
Rights Act), and two constitutional amendments
(the Twenty-Fourth outlawing the poll tax, and
the Twenty-Sixth lowering the voting age to 18),
making it an endeavor of notable endurance.
3. Promote
Equal Access to Public Accommodations. This
three-statute endeavor originates in the Civil
Rights Act of 1964, expands with the Open
Housing Act of 1968, and is capped with the
Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990. As
such, it shares one of its three statutory
foundations with the effort to eliminate
workplace discrimination and expand the right to
vote, confirming the enormous impact of the
Civil Rights Act as a core statute for the top
ten list. It is arguably the single-most
important statute on the original list of 538.
4. Reduce
Disease. The Polio Vaccination Act
of 1955 is the starting point for the most
eclectic group of statutes on the top ten list.
Alongside vaccination assistance, the effort to
reduce disease also includes targeted research
on heart disease, cancer, and stroke, bans on
smoking, strengthening the National Institutes
of Health, and lead-based poison prevention.
Despite this dispersion, the endeavor reflects a
clear commitment to reducing disease, whether
through specific interventions or broad research
investments.
5. Reduce
Workplace Discrimination. Seven
statutes anchor this effort to prohibit
workplace discrimination based on race, color,
religion, gender, national origin, age, or
disability, most notably the Civil Rights Act of
1964, the Age Discrimination Act of 1967, and
the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990. The
endeavor is a classic example of how an initial
breakthrough statute such as the Civil Rights
Act can provide a wedge for further expansion
over time.
6. Ensure
Safe Food and Drinking Water. Nine
statutes comprise this long-running bipartisan
effort, including the Federal Insecticide,
Fungicide, and Rodenticide Act of 1947 (signed
by Harry S. Truman), Poultry Products Inspection
Act of 1957 (signed by Dwight D. Eisenhower),
Wholesome Meat and Poultry Acts of 1967 and 1968
(signed by Lyndon Johnson), Federal
Environmental Pesticide Control Act (signed by
Richard M. Nixon), the Safe Drinking Water Act
of 1974 (signed by Gerald R. Ford), and the Food
Quality Protection Act of 1996 (signed by Bill
Clinton).
7. Strengthen
the Nation’s Highway System. Eight
statutes underpin the ongoing federal effort to
augment the national highway system, most
notably the 1956 Interstate Highway Act. The
multi-billion dollar expansions of highway aid
under the 1991 Intermodal Surface Transportation
Act (ISTEA) and 1998 Transportation Equity Act
for the Twenty-First Century make this endeavor
the most recently amended endeavor.
8. Increase Older Americans' Access to Health Care.
Medicare is the flagship of this highly
concentrated, three-statute endeavor, which also
includes the relatively small-scale Kerr-Mills
1960 precursor to Medicare and the now-defunct
Medicare Catastrophic Coverage Act of 1988. As
such, this is the only endeavor on the top ten
list that involved a single breakthrough
statute.
9. Reduce
the Federal Budget Deficit. Six
statutes fall under the effort to balance the
federal budget through caps, cuts, and tax
increases, including the Gramm-Rudman-Hollings
Anti-Deficit Act of 1985, and the 1987, 1990,
1993, and 1997 deficit reduction/tax increase
packages that contributed to the current budget
surpluses. Launched in the mid 1980s as budget
deficits swelled, this is the most recent
endeavor on the top ten list.
10. Promote
Financial Security in Retirement. Twenty-one
statutes comprise the effort to reduce poverty
among the elderly through expanded benefits,
pension protection, and individual savings,
including 12 increases in Social Security
benefits and two broad rescue attempts, the 1972
amendments to the Social Security Act that
created the Supplemental Security Income
program, and the Employment Retirement Income
Security Act (ERISA).
|